Recitatif
The short story Recitatif
takes the topic of race and sort of flips it on itself. Toni Morrison
creates this story where the race of both the main characters is never
explicitly said. Morrison places the characters in situations that test the
ethics of the reader into which race they assume each character is. These
situations really make the reader step back and realize how stereotypes play a
role in how you view the story. For example, the story opens with the two girls
meeting in the orphanage. Morrison supplies the reader with only two pieces of
information the girl’s names and what their mothers do that placed them in the
orphanage. Taking only these two facts with you as you read the story Morrison
asks the reader to make some key decisions as they read through the story. It
can be read from two different views depending on which race you assign each
girl. On the first read-through of the story, the mind selects the race for
each girl that it feels is best suited for that character based on the information
it was given about that girl’s life during the story. This highlights the
stereotypes of a race because it shows you what you unconsciously assume about
each race. It is my opinion that Morrison uses this shorty story the only one
of which she has ever written as a platform to show what effects stereotypes
have had on the unconscious mind. This story really does make you go back and read
it again and again searching for justification on why you assigned a race to
each character and a new clue pops up every time yet never solves the whole
puzzle.
I agree that Morrison's decision to not explicitly state the race of either Twyla or Roberta reveals more about the reader and our subconscious mind than it does the characters. Stereotypes throughout the story beg the reader to fill in the gaps yet an argument can be made that no matter what racial identity you assign to the girls, the story's commentary on racism is more effective when taken at face value as it explores the fact that prejudice and bias can exist in any culture or any race against another.
ReplyDelete